*If you are not very familiar with the Irish Health system, in order to understand better that post I recommend to read first that one Irish Health System For Dummies I – General Information.
Imagine yourself throwing 2000€ to the toilet at the beginning of every year, well, in general this image is not that far from what a family is doing when they sign up from private health insurance policy in Ireland.
When we arrived to Ireland, we didn’t know 100% how the things were working in many areas, even, a previous intense search for information about the place didn’t avoid us this uncertainty that most of people have when moving to a new country.
One of the first things we got sorted when we landed in Cork was a private health insurance for the family, if you do a search in the web many sites recommended you to get one in Ireland, even if you ask to the Irish people many of them will recommend it too, most of the times they cannot spot clearly the value of having it, but in any case we went for it and we paid around 1800€ for a year for 2 adults and 1 child.
That year my daugther got sick a couple of times, no major issues, winter virus, colds etc, normal stuff. So we went to the doctor two times, and naive me, I though after being paid 1800 euros, it would be free!!, to my surprise it wasn’t. It was the beginning of the end. I phoned the insurance company a bit upset and they explained me that my policy didn’t cover primary care and that we could go for a different policy next year where I could get the 50% back of the primary care expenses. It would cost a bit more, around 2000€ , but then they would return me a 50% of the day to day additional medical costs, what a bargain!!.
So at the end of the year with our private health insurance I spent (or partially wasted) in medical expenses, 1900 €, and we just went to the general practitioner two times!! Simplifying a lot 950€ per visit lol. Summarizing:
First Year: With Private Medical Insurance the Total Medical Expenses were 1900€, detailed as below:
1. The annual private insurance fee for the family (That’s the wasted part) – 1800€
2. The day to day medical expenses. – 100€
Then, having first-hand information for our first year experience together with the fact that in Ireland everybody* is covered by the public health system HSE, actually you’ll see for your monthly payslip that a reasonable amount of it goes in taxes to the HSE (www.hse.ie), we decided to quit from the private health insurance.
Second year started, by then we were four in the family, my youngest daughter arrived in November. This year was busier than the first one in terms of health care, we had to go:
– 4 times to the General Practitioner. 200€
– 1 To the emergency department. 100€
– 1 to the South Doc (60€) who sent our baby to the UCC hospital due to a bronchiolitis, and there we spent 1 night (75€)
Second year, Total Medical Costs without private insurance = 435€.
Big difference! isn’t? If I had kept my health insurance, from this 435€ I would have to have paid most of the costs except the 75€ of the hospital night, that was cover on the policy. So this would have been instead 360€ + 2000 € for the annual fee (4 members now). Total 2360€.
Even if you have a very bad year, remember you pay up two 10 nights in the hospital per year. 10 nights in the hospital = 750€ still very far from the 1900 € we paid first year. Normally if you have a major problem you’ll be sent to a public hospital.
Other thing some people are doing, is to save into an account the annual amount it would cost the private coverage for her/his entire family. So in case of a contingency or for example you don’t want to wait two years to get your knee operated, you can use that money for that purpose.
There are positives in the private health insurance too, the main one is that you can cut the waits, so if you are likely to go often to the doctor private insurance will avoid all the hassle of long waitings, a long waiting is the last thing you want when you are sick, and Public Hospitals in Ireland are not the best in that. Also for minor injuries that require surgery you may wait around two years using the public system, with the private insurance it wouldn’t be the case.
Some companies pay the private health insurance for their employees, if it is your case, there is no doubt, go for it!
This is just my opinion based on my experience. I hope you find the topic interesting, if you do a search in the web, in the Irish forums there are a lot of debate around it with all kind of opinions.
*A person living in Ireland for at least one year is considered by the HSE to be ‘ordinarily resident’ and is entitled to either full eligibility (Category 1) or limited eligibility (Category 2) for health services.
People who have not been resident in Ireland for at least one year must satisfy the HSE that it is their intention to remain for a minimum of one year in order to be eligible for health services. Dependants of such individuals must also contact the HSE to confirm their eligibility. http://www.hse.ie/eng/services/Find_a_Service/eligibility.html